Varying marijuana laws pose questions for air travelers Marijuana – Miracle treatment for children with autism Marijuana workers get the California seal of approval Is Legal Marijuana the Last Bipartisan Cause in America? Marijuana activists vow to smoke and get arrested on steps of U.S. Capitol Most Americans Support Pro Athletes Using Marijuana for Pain Relief California Cannabis Is Going Industrial Trump’s drug czar pick has strong “no” vote record on marijuana Billions In Marijuana Taxes Are Addictive To State Governors The Holy Land of Medical Marijuana Oregon lawmakers vote to block cannabis users’ info from feds Marijuana legalization grows closer with Senate tax proposal Jerry Jones’s marijuana proposal could save NFL players’ lives The problem with America’s marijuana DUI laws John Oliver – Update Federal Marijuana Laws The way people buy legal marijuana will change in 2019 DOJ Wants Information On Colorado Marijuana Cases Oregon lawmakers introduce laws to protect legal recreational marijuana Public support for legal marijuana surged in 2016 Federal Marijuana Hostility Wrong Addiction Specialists Ponder a Potential Aid: Marijuana Dozens of industries could see a boost from legal marijuana Oregon May Declare Emergency Over Jeff Sessions’ Marijuana Threats Maximizing the Medical Effects of Marijuana Marijuana Legalization Opponents Were Wrong Oxford University announces new £10m medical marijuana research program Pro-marijuana church in Alabama: Members tout ‘God and cannabis’ Every State Could Legalize Marijuana by 2021- The Motley Fool 25% of US beer drinkers have switched to marijuana or would if it was legal Colorado Rep. Jared Polis has a plan to keep marijuana safe from Sessions Good science on marijuana is hard to find Jeff Sessions: Marijuana Is “Only Slightly Less Awful” Than Heroin Federal Marijuana Crimes Drop For Fifth Consecutive Year Jeff Sessions Will Enforce Federal Marijuana Laws In An ‘Appropriate Way’ Beer Industry Could Lose $2 Billion From Legal Marijuana Pot for pets: Owners treat sick animals with marijuana Marijuana Legalization Hasn’t Increased Traffic Fatalities Don’t let Big Marijuana prioritize profits over public safety The future of recreational marijuana in Trump’s America Idaho customers breathe life into tiny Oregon marijuana town Elizabeth Warren to Jeff Sessions “Respect state marijuana law” Doctors warn against teen pot use as marijuana laws loosen Will Edible And Concentrate Marijuana Brands Get As Big As Budweiser? Marijuana Industry To Create More Jobs Than Manufacturing By 2020 California Marijuana Is Not Safe to Smoke California marijuana tax and tracking systems behind schedule Republican Introduces “The Respect State Marijuana Laws Act” Why the Legal Marijuana Industry Is Suddenly Worried Military Veterans With PTSD Begin Marijuana Clinical Trials Marijuana Drug Could Extend Lives of Brain Cancer Patients, Study Finds Contaminated Medical Marijuana Believed To Have Killed California Cancer Patient Marijuana lobby goes mainstream Marijuana Prices Fall As Growers Flood The Market With Pot Scientists to Government: Make It Easier to Investigate Marijuana Likely scenarios for marijuana under Jeff Sessions as attorney general Six Predictions For The Marijuana Industry In 2017 Study finds traffic fatalities decline with medical marijuana laws This Company Is Using Brain Scans To Help You Select Medical Marijuana DEA dismissed its own misconceptions about marijuana Duke University Uses Identical Twins to Prove Weed Doesn’t Make Kids Dumb Marijuana industry brought to a standstill by pesticide testing problems Massachusetts Marijuana – Now What? Trump’s Attorney General Is a Bad Scenario for the Marijuana Industry Pharma executive behind OxyContin sells medical marijuana Marijuana Plants Flourish Under Energy-Saving LED Lights Legal Marijuana Could Drive A New Tech Boom California marijuana would fail Oregon’s standards, study finds When Medical Marijuana Is the Doctor’s Orders, Will Insurers Pay? Marijuana Sales Spike at Thanksgiving Legal marijuana users can’t legally buy a gun Maine marijuana legalization nears recount California marijuana industry is a ‘$25 billion opportunity’ NFL Players Searching For Painkiller Choices Hope For New Marijuana Rules Test for marijuana impairment? A UMass prof has an app for that States Offer Legal Marijuana – Investors And Marketers Line Up Washington Marijuana Outsells Liquor Colorado’s paradox: Recreational marijuana is legal, but it’s tough to use Attorney General Selection Signals Hazy Future for Marijuana Legalization Marijuana: Will it soon be bigger than the NFL? Will Legal Marijuana Lead To More People Smoking Tobacco? A legal snafu made medical marijuana tax-free in California for 2017 Advocates Wait for Trump’s Stance on Legal Marijuana Marijuana may help control substance abuse, mental health disorders California Marijuana is Legal. Now What? Legislators file bills aimed at decriminalizing Texas marijuana Massachusetts Marijuana gold rush? Walmart of Weed? Not so fast CDC: More people are using marijuana, but fewer are abusing it Industrial hemp industry gets kick-start from oil extract US court upholds ban on selling guns to marijuana card holders Marijuana startups could be hurt once legalization hits Marijuana Drug Helps Kids With Rare Forms Of Epilepsy In Studies Libertarian Gary Johnson Explains Why He Supports Legal Marijuana U.S. Gov’t Will Legalize Marijuana on August 1 Police and Prison Guard Groups Fight Marijuana Legalization in California Study: States are losing out on billions of dollars by keeping marijuana illegal New law could put some medical marijuana dispensaries out of business Will Canada become America’s cannabis capital? Talking With Teenagers About Marijuana Jay Evensen: Americans embrace marijuana blindly Vacant California prison could be turned into marijuana production site

Marijuana legalization grows closer with Senate tax proposal

Marijuana legalization

marijuana legalization

Want to legalize marijuana federally? Propose sensible taxes on the drug.

That’s the tactic of a new bill from two Oregon Democrats: House Ways and Means Committee member Earl Blumenauer and ranking Senate Finance Committee member Ron Wyden. It takes on tough marijuana legalization questions: What should a marijuana tax measure? Should it tax medical marijuana? The Marijuana Revenue and Regulation Act (MRRA) provides thoughtful answers.

What to tax?

The 64-page bill, S. 776, and House companions H.R. 1823 and 1841, starts out problematically, taxing marijuana by price for a five-year transition period, but ends up brilliantly, with sophisticated weight-based taxes for the long run. A companion bill repeals the useful current tax on advertising.


For its first five years, the MRRA taxes marijuana by percentage of producer price, with rates ratcheting up from 10 percent to 25 percent.

Taxing by price means that when the pre-tax price goes down, taxes do, too. So do after-tax prices. Low taxes and cheap weed are not on everyone’s wish list. After marijuana legalization, pre-tax prices are bound to wither. Fully legal marijuana won’t sell for hundreds or even dozens of dollars per ounce, pre-tax. Is the MRRA’s final 25 percent rate high enough? Will five years be too long? No one knows. As a tax design architect — yes, that’s a thing — I’ll leave the numbers to the economists.


But price taxes create another problem. In case of “vertical integration” like a farm-to-market operation, the bill shies away from taxing the actual price the consumer pays, so it imagines an artificial — and probably arbitrary — “constructive [producer] price … determined by the Secretary” of the Treasury. This is the amount one person, who is both retail clerk and farmer, supposedly pays his farmer self as a wholesale price. Shenanigans galore! Colorado has this kind of unworkable producer price tax on the books but, finding it doesn’t work, has quietly given up. Colorado taxes producers by weight instead.


Eventually, after five years of marijuana legalization, the MRRA taxes “concentrates” — processed marijuana used in liquid form or put into “edibles,” as when baked into cookies — by the number of grams they contain of marijuana’s primary intoxicant, tetrahydrocannabinol (THC). Chemistry reveals the amount of THC in the processed product. So far, so good.

As for unprocessed plant material — “naturally grown and unadulterated marijuana flower,” the bill taxes by the ounce.

That’s less theoretically beautiful, but it makes perfect sense. Measuring THC in flower involves guesswork, sampling error and gamesmanship. Ever wonder why no jurisdiction taxes cigarettes by nicotine content? Nicotine, like THC in the marijuana flower, is too tricky to measure accurately enough for the government work of taxation. Sure, taxing by weight incentivizes powerful marijuana — stuff that’s rich in THC. But unless we’re willing to take the seller’s word for THC content, the MRRA’s Colorado-style weight tax on flowers is the best we can hope for.

How much per gram or per ounce will the MRRA charge in taxes eventually? It has a formula designed to keep the amount of tax owed the same after the five-year transition ends. It aims to convert the price tax burden — the amount of tax owed — to a weight tax burden.

Technically, it takes the per-ounce “prevailing sales price” of flower during the fifth and final price-tax year, multiplies it by that year’s 25 percent tax rate, and makes that the per-ounce tax on flower. For THC measured in concentrates, the per-ounce rate is 10 times the flower rate. That’s an equivalent for flower that is 10 percent THC by weight. Commendably, the bill adjusts those tax rates annually for marijuana price inflation.

A final word about federal design: Federal taxes need to be high enough to prevent the kind of interstate tax arbitrage that causes criminals to buy low-taxed cigarettes at retail in Virginia to resell illegally in New York. Marijuana is enormously more valuable by weight and volume than tobacco. A high federal tax, high enough to dominate the field, would address that problem. A credit for state taxes paid could leave states whole.

More from

Facebook Comments

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: